Short Summary

Garber Park is a 13-acre wildland park owned by the City of Oakland located behind the Claremont Hotel in Claremont Canyon. Garber Park is home to significant stands of big-leaf maple, California buckeyes and regenerating coast live oak woodland and forest. The Garber Park Stewards vision is to safeguard the native wildland resources of Garber Park while reducing the risk of wildfire and improving the trail system.

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Citizen Science Workshop: Sudden Oak Death: Strategies for Facing the Pathogen in Garber Park

On April 7, the Garber Park Stewards were pleased to host a Citizen Science Workshop focused on Sudden Oak Death, presented and led by Lech Naumovich, Ecologist, of the Golden Hour Restoration Institute.

Well-attended by naturalists, arborists, landscapers, trail workers, and interested citizens, the workshop provided in depth instruction and commentary on the current state of research and understanding about the disease. Click here for a PDF of Lech’s excellent 4 page handout on SOD resources.  In some ways more compelling than an update on the research, this workshop provided hands on and eye witness evidence of the existence and the material indicia of SOD infection in the oak forest of Garber Park.

It is one thing to look at photographs of the pathogen and its effects on living forests, but it is quite another to recognize the characteristic bleed of an infected tree right in front of you.  Perhaps counterintuitively, the pathogen slowly and methodically kills an oak tree by girdling the main stem.  Looking directly at this process, you cannot avoid an increasing appreciation of the complexity of the SOD blight in the landscape that surrounds you. Even the ground breaking research of Matteo Garbelotto’s UC Sudden Oak Death Lab does not suggest a strategy for “saving” a forest under attack.

The pathogen itself is a recent (within the last 20 years) stowaway on nursery stock (probably rhododendrons) and within its own biological limits has spread rapidly into Northern California backyards and forests which are evolutionarily unprepared to fend it off.  The bleed on an infected oak is evidence of resistance in the victim, but the functions of immunity are poorly understood to date. The highly vulnerable tan oak forests of Marin County exhibit a mortality rate over 90% while the Coast Live Oaks exhibit only 55% mortality—perhaps due to innate or developing immunity.  Currently available chemical treatments aim to boost the immune response of particular trees in order to save them. But a forest is a great deal more than a de facto gathering of particular trees.

In the complex riparian woodland of Garber Park, each of the four constituent trees (and many shrubs) is affected by the pathogen.  The Big Leaf Maple and the California Buckeye are passive carriers.  The pathogen aggressively feeds on the leaves of the Bay Laurels without killing the tree and the Bay Laurels serve as a vector for the conveyance of the pathogen through the forest.
The Coast Live Oak appears to be an unintended victim and a dead end for the pathogen.  An infected oak has not been shown to transmit the pathogen to another host. Yet, the possible consequence of 55% mortality of Garber’s Coast Live Oaks is a circumstance of great magnitude from every point of view including the loss of mature canopy and fire hazard that would exist from numerous downed heritage oaks.

As the Workshop demonstrated, there are no solutions or prescriptions at this time for “saving” an infected forest, though there may be ways to “save” an infected tree.  Deepening research and increasing experience of arborists may hasten the time when there are proven strategies.  But there are many things we can do now as interested individuals and groups.  We can support the work of the SOD Lab by participating in the upcoming SOD Blitz at the end of April.  The Garber Park Stewards are using the SOD Blitz to better assess the rate and range of infection exhibited by Bay Laurels.  Using a grid system we will collect apparently symptomatic leaves and submit them for testing.  The results will be available in October. 

Sign up now to help with the SOD Blitz 2012 on the weekend of April 28-29 Attend a one-hour long training offered by U.C. Berkeley Dr. Matteo Garbelotto, and then collect symptomatic bay leaves.  Return samples to a drop box at the training site by Sunday evening. To sign up for the UC Berkeley training, go to  To help in Garber Park contact

We can hone our understanding by recognizing the pathogen and closely observing its operations in Garber Park’s forest.  Phytopthera ramorum is an invader which may become endemic. Whether by direct intervention or more passive strategies,  it behooves us to do as much as we can to spare our native landscape the worst effects of this pathogen.